Star Style Wars: The ‘He’s Just Not That Into You’ premiere

6a00d8341c873353ef01116842c

He’s Just Not That Into You has a dazzling array of female stars (only two of whom aren’t called Jennifer/Ginnifer, which must have made things confusing on set), so naturally, when the film premiered this week, The Fashion Police decided to start a Style War between them all.

You’ll find pictures of Drew Barrymore, Jenifer Connelly, Scarlett Johansson, Jennifer Aniston and Ginnifer Goodwin under the jump. Your task is simple: tell us who you thought was best dressed. And, if you feel like it, tell us who you thought was worst dressed, too…

Spl77626_005[2]

Drew wins points for hair and makeup, but we don’t think this droopy dress is doing her any favour…

Spl77626_013[1] 

Va-voom! Jennifer Connelly looks more like a catwalk model every time we see her. Love her work with the Balmain heels…

Spl77626_025[1] 

A pretty pink floral dress for Scarlett, who has also gone brunette.

Spl76779_008[1] 

Jennifer Aniston goes for the “sharp suit” look we’ve been seeing a lot of on the red carpet recently. She also became a victim of the Foot Snatcher, poor woman.

Spl76831_030[1] 

This is nice enough, but when you’re side-by-side with such A-listers, we think you need something a little more special, Ginnifer…

23 Comments

  • February 3, 2009

    Nina

    Ginnifer wins by far! Even though you’re right, it’s not the most awesome dress I’ve ever seen. But for Drew: droopy dress, lipstick too bright. Jennifer C.: Are those padded shoulders?? Not very feminine, reminds me of the green Goblin. Scarlett: nice dress, but what’s with the hair… Don’t like it. Jennifer A.: You would’ve won, but the foot snatcher thwarted your plans!

    View Comment
  • February 3, 2009

    Am

    Jennifer C looks like a Drag Queen! That dress is too short and shiny and the padded shoulders should be locked up in your fashion jail for all eternity…
    As for the rest, Scarlett gets my vote, and I would be gushing about that dress if it didn’t remind me so much of curtains, but the cut is excellent and makes her look fab. Everyone else looks good but not amazing. And I disagree about Drew’s make-up (her hair is great!)Those lips are too pale!

    View Comment
  • February 3, 2009

    Lee

    I love that Connelly doesn’t wear the same boring dresses as the rest of hollywood. She doesn’t play it safe, she takes risks and for that, I think she wins this round.

    View Comment
  • February 3, 2009

    Belle

    Jennifer Connelly looks the best by far! I’m not liking Scarlett Johansons new hair at all, Drew looks so-so & Jennifer Aniston looks okay I guess..
    I like Giniffer Goodwins dress but not the shoes or accessories..

    View Comment
  • February 3, 2009

    Natasha

    Hmmm, I’d say Jennifer Connelly, but I might be biased cause I really like her… I swear, that woman is so gorgeous, she could pull off a garbage sack!
    Drew – lips too pale, hair too inconspicuous, and the dress makes her look fat.

    View Comment
  • February 3, 2009

    Rock Hyrax

    I prefer Scarlett Johansson’s outfit.

    View Comment
  • February 3, 2009

    Marianne

    There are parts of each outfit I like, be it shoes or cut or color. But they don’t look like they are attending the same event, which is bugging me. We’ve got everything here from a strapless gown with train to sharp slacks and a jacket. Did they all have better places to go after?

    View Comment
  • February 3, 2009

    franbeanika

    At first I hated Jen C but the more I look at it the more I like it, it’s fierce and daring.
    Personally, I always love Jen A’s laid back look and she is working it here perfectly, her beatifully soft hair add femininity and the bling is fab.
    I didn’t even recognise Scarlett, where’s the ‘pop’ we saw in her make up ad recently, bring back the blonde and the vamp girl, you ain’t no plain jane (and I’m a brunette saying this!!)

    View Comment
  • February 3, 2009

    gokarm

    Scar Jo’s dress is a most flattering cut but the pattern is distractingly unpleasant. And yeah, she needs to be blond. For me, Aniston wins because it’s the least costumy and the most appropriate. Connelly is merely continuing her balenciaga trend…not a fan of the line and I just PREFER a softer Connelly. “Fierce” doesn’t suit her personality, she’s too mature. And I think Drew looks absolutely darling, but I wish the dress had a bit more structure around the bust. the left side looks like it fell apart. Goodwin…eh, boring in a tropical vacation sorta way. Not bad, but not appropriate either.

    View Comment
  • February 3, 2009

    Amanda Nicole

    If it weren’t for the foot snatcher I would’ve chosen Jennifer Aniston, but as it is I think Scarlett’s look suits her the best. I miss the blonde though!

    View Comment
  • February 3, 2009

    Becky

    I personally really like Drew’s look…i think she looks fresh and beautiful, lips and all! I would say best dressed is a tossup b/w her and Scarlett. Jennifer Aniston is looking pretty hot too, despite the foot snatcher. Not really feeling Jennifer C’s outfit…and i agree that Ginnifer just looks…kinda boring.

    View Comment
  • February 3, 2009

    Rhonda

    Jennifer Aniston is top class! (Even without feet!) She added the right touch of accessories. Scarlett’s dress could be second if she did a little something to her hair. Actually all of them could have done better with the hair.

    View Comment
  • February 3, 2009

    Celeste

    I think Scarlett Johansson’s is my favorite. Though maybe she should have done something with her hair. Next is Jennifer Aniston, though she’d look better with feet, and if her hair was out of her face. Then Ginnifer Goodwin who has a good outfit, just not premier appropriate.
    And the bad. The pale, floppy thing on Drew’s top annoys me. And she needs some color, pale top and pale makeup isn’t working. And Jennifer Connely’s dress is awful. Like someone hacked the skirt and sleeves off an old lady’s ball gown. Also the shoulder pads. When you manage to wear a sequined dress and look more masculine than a woman in a suit, there’s a problem.

    View Comment
  • February 3, 2009

    nj

    they all have something a little bit off…drew’s poor deflated boob, jen a’s disturbing shoulderpads, scarlet’s bedsheet pattern, jen c’s missing feet, gin’s cute but oops-i-didn’t-realize-you-4-were-going-dressy outfit…but overall that just makes those 5 uber gorgeous women seem more like the rest of us so i kinda love them all…especially jen c’s shoes 😀

    View Comment
  • February 3, 2009

    SB

    I think Scarlett Johansson & Jennifer Aniston are really the most stylish and beautiful. They both went with sort of cool, classic looks (though the pattern on Johansson’s dress is a bit loud, but she pulls it off). Also, neither Johansson nor Aniston are “putting it out there” like the other three. The others all look like they are trying too hard – we know you have legs, but we don’t need to see them in their entirety.

    View Comment
  • February 3, 2009

    Unuvoi

    Drew!

    View Comment
  • February 3, 2009

    chocoholic

    I love Scarlett’s dress. Curtain fabric and all!
    But her hair is a bit boring.
    Next I like Jen A, she looks fab in the suit, but compared to the others it makes her look a little old.
    3rd is Ginnifer. I really like her cute outfit, but its not really dressy enough.
    Drew and Jen C come last equal. Drew’s dress is hideously inflattering and Jen’s horrid dress makes her look like a man.

    View Comment
  • February 4, 2009

    Julieta

    drew barrymore’s dress doesn’t flatter her, the ponytail makes her look sweet and young, but what’s with the hidious lipstick? the earrings are cute, but that dress just doesn’t work at all.
    jennifer conelly, I LOVE THOSE SHOES! I like the dress but I think she’s too old for it, and too thin, I’d rather see her in a flowing, LONGER gown, she looks kind of sick on that and the hair is not helping.
    scarlet johansson, I think she looked way better when she was blond, she looks older, and BORING, and i just hate the dress it reminds me of one of my grandma’s swimsuits (but longer)
    Jennifer Aniston, she’s gorgeous, her hair looks great, her face looks fresh and natural, I’m going to overlook the fact that she’s wearing a suit and a foot snatcher because she might still be sad about Brad,,. who wouln’t though?
    Ginnifer Goodwin, love her from head to toes, lovely flattering dress, beautiful heels, the matching purse,.. the only thing I don’t like is that necklace it doesn’t match the dress, it doesn’t work for me I think she would look way more sofisticated without it, and maybe with a brighter lipstick.
    my favourite outfit is Jennifer Connely’s but I’m not loving any of them.
    I don’t get it, with all that money how can they look so … regular.

    View Comment
  • February 4, 2009

    Maddie

    Scarlett: Best
    Jennifer: Worst

    View Comment
  • February 4, 2009

    Caroline

    Ginnifer looks outrageously cute and fresh faced.
    I actually like Drew’s dress as well as her hair but think the lippy does NOTHING for her!
    Jen C’s dress looks to me like she’s auditioning for the role of The Green Goblin – love the colour, but horrendous!
    Jen A’s outfit is amazingly chic – she looks statuesque and utterly glamorous!
    But for me Scarlett’s dress is the winner – sooo beautiful, and perfect for her figure!

    View Comment
  • February 4, 2009

    b.

    Am, I agree. Connelly totally looks like a transvestite.

    View Comment
  • March 4, 2010

    bb

    It’s funny, if you swapped these outfits around there would be better results. Connelly’s outfit would look rockin on Aniston’s fit physique and Aniston’s would rock Barrymore. Connelly would be lovely and soft in Scarlet’s outfit and wish her new darker hair Scarlet would be flattered by the silky part in Barrymore’s dress. I think Ginnifer’s dress suits her the best out of all of the looks and with just a simple change of jewlery (even Drew’s earings and no necklace) she would be the obvious winner.

    View Comment
  • March 17, 2010

    Alex

    I think Jennifer Anniston looked the best.
    .-= Alex´s last blog ..Alice in Wonderland =-.

    View Comment