Best Dressed of the Day: Cate Blanchett, Christina Milian, Liv Tyler or Taylor Momsen?

Cate Blanchett, Christina Milian, Liv Tyler or Taylor Momsen

One of these glamorously dressed ladies looks like a Fashion Criminal to us. At least one other is deserving of a Fashion Police badge for good behaviour. What we want to know is whether you share our thoughts on these fine celebrities, which is why we’re asking once again: who was the best dressed of the day?

Was it Cate Blanchett, in her metallic gown, Christina Milian, who looks like she’s already won some kind of medal, a newly single and slightly gothic looking Liv Tyler, or did little Jenny Humphrey, aka Taylor Momsen float The Fashion Police boat? And which is the fashion criminal?

Look under the jump for bigger pictures of the celebrities, and a poll which will help us decide who was the best dressed of the day!

Cate Blanchett, Christina Milian

Cate Blanchett, Christina Milian

Liv Tyler, Taylor Momsen

Liv Tyler, Taylor Momsen

14 Comments

  • May 21, 2008

    Veronika

    I like Liv’s look too but think Taylor had it down the most. And Cate? Why the potatoe sack?! Is it some Olsen twin influence that worked its magic on you? Sorry, but mostly you are amazing but this is a fashion crime..

    View Comment
  • May 21, 2008

    The Fashion Police

    Veronika, if it’s us you think Cate’s dress “worked its magic on”, you’ll notice that we DID say one of the women pictured is a fashion criminal, in our opinion…

    View Comment
  • May 21, 2008

    Veronika

    Ohh I didnt mean on you YOU but on you Cate:D Anyways I did gather that you meant Cate as the criminal here. But usually she’s so good with dresses, so its quite the let down, isnt it?

    View Comment
  • May 21, 2008

    Veronika

    And I think you (FP) are also mostly amazing;) Just to set things straight!

    View Comment
  • May 21, 2008

    Ella

    Yuck to Cate’s dress! And Christina could stand to lose the medal, but it is a nice dress under that.
    I voted Taylor for best dressed.

    View Comment
  • May 21, 2008

    Danielle

    I don’t like ANY of them. The only two that might be decent are Christina’s and Taylor, but Christina’s looks like a cheap $50 dress from the junior’s section of Macy’s that always has holes and runs in the cheap fabric, and Taylor looks like she’s trying to be Tinkerbell.

    View Comment
  • May 21, 2008

    Abby

    I would say that Cate and Christina are the fashion criminals. Normally Cate dresses beautifully, but this time her dress is horrible. I agree with Veronika, it looks like a shiny potatoe sack. As for Christina’s dress, alone it was already rather cheap looking, but she’s gone and made it worse with the ugly medal she’s wearing.

    View Comment
  • May 21, 2008

    Sophia

    1) Cate looks like she gathered a ton of shiny fabric from a fabric store and “strategically” draped it around herself.
    2) Christina’s dress with or without the medal looks cheap and tacky.
    3) Liv Tyler, why so gloomy?
    4) The last girl is DEFINITELY the winner

    View Comment
  • May 22, 2008

    Anna

    I love Liv’s dress, but I hate the makeup

    View Comment
  • May 22, 2008

    Laura

    I think they all look shocking to be honest. Tinkerbell is the least offensive!

    View Comment
  • May 22, 2008

    Beth

    Somehow Taylor looks sort of like she’s dressed for the prom, but nevertheless the dress is a nice colour on her and it’s interesting without going down the “shiny potato sack” road like Cate has. Taylor’s clearly the best dressed – and I want a pair of those shoes!

    View Comment
  • May 22, 2008

    Paiton

    I think Taylor Momsen is DEFINETLY the best dressed. Sure she looked a little bit like Tinker Bell but it was cute. Liv Tyler had a good idea with the “little black dress” theme but I think she made it look a little more gothic than chic. Christina Milan dress looked cute to go to a school dance in or somting, but she definetly didn’t look ready for the red carpet. And what was up with that medal she was wearing?? TACKY!!!! I think Cate Blanchett was the real criminal here she looked like she was a farmhand trying to be a diva or somthing! Total disapointment Cate.

    View Comment
  • May 27, 2008

    Diana

    Cate´s sack is hideous.
    Christina´s dress looks cheap and the shoes and the MEDAL are ugly.
    Taylor´s fairy-like dress is horrible.
    I voted Liv for the best dressed, I love the look though I don´t like the shoes.

    View Comment
  • December 5, 2008

    bebe

    there’s nothing wrong with taylors outfit and christina should just take off the medal and she’d be good to go. but the metalic one kills me. i am highly upset now. arrest her, lock her up, and throw the keys into the mouth of a whale that migrates to anartica !

    View Comment