Star Style Wars: Angelina Jolie V. Liv Tyler

Starstylewars

It’s Monday and it’s raining, so it’s time to play an all-new Fashion Police game. The rules are simple: two stars, two similar outfits – you tell us who wore it best.

This week for your inspection we have Angelina Jolie and Liv Tyler, both working the pencil skirt, v-neck sweater and peep toes look. This is an outfit which could be described as either "classic" or "boring" depending on how charitable you’re feeling. I love it, and I think this is a close one to call. Angelina is never less than elegant, but I have a bit of a girl-crush on Liv, who I think just has the edge here – and the nicest shoes.

What do you think? Angelina or Liv – who wears it best?

9 Comments

  • Reply October 15, 2007

    Chica

    I love Liv’s look, and it is the one i’d more readily wear if i was trying to look classy and demure, rather than my more colourful self :)

  • Reply October 15, 2007

    Laura V

    I think Liv does it better! On Angie, it exposes a bit too much bony chest (please, Angie, gain like 10 lbs, I’m begging you).

  • Reply October 15, 2007

    Haley

    Angelina Jolie would do well to never get in any kind of confrontation with Liv Tyler, a stiff breeze might blow her into traffic and that would be a mess, but Liv Tyler is radiantly beautiful in this outfit, the elf costume, the creepy Aerosmith videos from the ’90s. It doesn’t matter. Although I do like the simple classicness of this outfit.
    Also, is that chartreuse? Yuck. Does ANYONE look good in chartruese?

  • Reply October 16, 2007

    Monica H

    *waving hand* I look good in chartreuse. But I am a brown girl. LOL
    I like AJ’s look better, just not on her, sso by default…Liv

  • Reply October 16, 2007

    WendyB

    I feel uncharitable and am too bored by both outfits to pick one I prefer. :-P

  • Reply October 16, 2007

    Caroline

    Liv wins hands down for me – you need some shape to carry this off, and her perfect hair and delicate necalce add to the polish. But in all honesty, I adore Liv, and don’t actually like looking at Angelina Jolie as I’m scared a mis-judged sneeze might snap her frail body in twain.

  • Reply October 16, 2007

    sarah trot

    I think Angelina’s looks more interesting, colour is always a nice thing to have… but Liv wins for be because it’s so much more put-together and classy.
    Maybe it’s the way that Angelina is walking, but it looks like the cut of her sweater at the bottom doesn’t work so nicely with the skirt.

  • Reply October 16, 2007

    Kerry

    Definately Liv Tyler. I really hate the ‘one-solid-block-colour-with-black’ look. Second only to the ‘one-solid-pastel-colour-with-black’ look. I much prefer the monochrome of Liv. Plus she’s gorgeous and immaculately groomed here.

  • Reply October 21, 2007

    Issie

    Liv Tyler! Im hating the colour of that cardi that Angelina is wearing. It looks like one of her children puked in the washing machine…

Leave a Reply