Star Style Wars: Angelina Jolie V. Liv Tyler


It’s Monday and it’s raining, so it’s time to play an all-new Fashion Police game. The rules are simple: two stars, two similar outfits – you tell us who wore it best.

This week for your inspection we have Angelina Jolie and Liv Tyler, both working the pencil skirt, v-neck sweater and peep toes look. This is an outfit which could be described as either "classic" or "boring" depending on how charitable you’re feeling. I love it, and I think this is a close one to call. Angelina is never less than elegant, but I have a bit of a girl-crush on Liv, who I think just has the edge here – and the nicest shoes.

What do you think? Angelina or Liv – who wears it best?


  • October 15, 2007


    I love Liv’s look, and it is the one i’d more readily wear if i was trying to look classy and demure, rather than my more colourful self :)

  • October 15, 2007

    Laura V

    I think Liv does it better! On Angie, it exposes a bit too much bony chest (please, Angie, gain like 10 lbs, I’m begging you).

  • October 15, 2007


    Angelina Jolie would do well to never get in any kind of confrontation with Liv Tyler, a stiff breeze might blow her into traffic and that would be a mess, but Liv Tyler is radiantly beautiful in this outfit, the elf costume, the creepy Aerosmith videos from the ’90s. It doesn’t matter. Although I do like the simple classicness of this outfit.
    Also, is that chartreuse? Yuck. Does ANYONE look good in chartruese?

  • October 16, 2007

    Monica H

    *waving hand* I look good in chartreuse. But I am a brown girl. LOL
    I like AJ’s look better, just not on her, sso by default…Liv

  • October 16, 2007


    I feel uncharitable and am too bored by both outfits to pick one I prefer. 😛

  • October 16, 2007


    Liv wins hands down for me – you need some shape to carry this off, and her perfect hair and delicate necalce add to the polish. But in all honesty, I adore Liv, and don’t actually like looking at Angelina Jolie as I’m scared a mis-judged sneeze might snap her frail body in twain.

  • October 16, 2007

    sarah trot

    I think Angelina’s looks more interesting, colour is always a nice thing to have… but Liv wins for be because it’s so much more put-together and classy.
    Maybe it’s the way that Angelina is walking, but it looks like the cut of her sweater at the bottom doesn’t work so nicely with the skirt.

  • October 16, 2007


    Definately Liv Tyler. I really hate the ‘one-solid-block-colour-with-black’ look. Second only to the ‘one-solid-pastel-colour-with-black’ look. I much prefer the monochrome of Liv. Plus she’s gorgeous and immaculately groomed here.

  • October 21, 2007


    Liv Tyler! Im hating the colour of that cardi that Angelina is wearing. It looks like one of her children puked in the washing machine…